Colombe Jacobsen-Derstine
Hailey
Rick Baker
MIB Passport Control Agent
Jeremy Howard
Bird Guy Alien / Postal Sorting Alien
Denise Cheshire
Family Mom / Locker Alien
Chloë Sonnenfeld
Young Girl at Post Office
Paige Brooks
'Mysteries in History' Lauranna
Michael Beardsley
Suspicious Video Store Patron
Patrick Coleman Duncan
'History's Mysteries' Alien
Martin Pfefferkorn
Homeless Alien Collaborater
Peter Siragusa
Mayor of Grand Central Terminal Locker Aliens